Leader view
If your leaders have done all the training, why are they still not ready for the bigger job?
In the first issue of Leader View, we looked at a familiar mistake: assuming the person who performs best today is the person most ready for tomorrow. In the second, we offered a way to test readiness with evidence instead of a rating. This issue asks the next question: once you know who is ready and who is not, how do you build readiness?
Consider a director called Rachel. Over three years she read the books, attended two national conferences, and completed an executive program. Her file was thick with certificates. Then she was asked to lead a cross-functional initiative with peers she did not manage and a deadline she did not set. She struggled. The courses did not prepare her well. Rachel's story is not a story of laziness or low ability. It is a story of development that was filled with activities, but did not change what she could do.
The problem is not that organizations spend too little on development. It is that they spend it on methods that don’t change behavior. A method's value is not measured by how much people enjoy it or how good it looks on paper. It is measured by what a leader can do differently afterward, under real pressure, without an instructor.
Before you read the list of development options, pause. Think about how you, or your organization, have invested in leadership development over the past year or two. Where did the money and the calendar time go, and what was the return? Keep your answers in mind as we assess the pros and cons of each method.
The leadership development options
Reading a book. A book is the cheapest development. It gives a leader language and models, and it can be done around a full-time job. What it cannot do is give feedback to the reader. There is no one to point out where the reader's judgment went wrong, and no consequence for stopping at understanding instead of doing. Reading builds knowledge. Leadership capability is not built reading a book.
Attending a conference. A conference gives a leader two things a book cannot: the company of other people and a break from routine. Conversations in hallways between sessions can shift a perspective. But the research on retention is clear. Without follow-up, most of what a conference delivers fades within weeks. A conference is exposure to new ideas, but these alone do not change behavior.
An on-site training program. Bringing a program inside the company has clear advantages. The examples are your own, the language becomes shared, and a whole team hears the same thing at the same time. The limit is the room itself. A classroom can teach a model, but it cannot reproduce the pressure of a real decision with real stakes. On-site training works best when the leader is required to apply what they learned back on the job.
An off-site training program. Sending leaders away has a different appeal. Distance from daily demands creates room to think, and peers from other companies offer comparison a single company cannot. The price can be high, in money and in time away, and the same question follows leaders home: What will change on Monday morning? Lasting value comes from translating insight into action.
Cross-functional work. Give a leader work outside their own function, and something different happens. They see how decisions land in parts of the business they never had to consider, and they learn to influence people who do not report to them. This is the closest most organizations come to practicing the next job while doing the current one. It takes sponsorship and time, because a leader's own manager must be willing to share them with another team.
Stretch assignments. The Center for Creative Leadership keeps finding that the assignments that stretch a leader teach them more than any training course. A stretch assignment puts judgment, influence, and resilience to a real test, with consequences that cannot be simulated. The risk with stretch assignments is high. Without support and feedback, a stretch assignment becomes sink or swim, and the organization learns nothing except that the leader sank.
Mentoring. A mentor provides something no formal program can: the perspective of someone who has already navigated the challenges, decisions, and mistakes a developing leader is likely to encounter. Studies have consistently linked mentoring to stronger career outcomes and higher levels of professional satisfaction. The results depend on the match and on structure. A mentoring relationship left to chance often becomes a pleasant lunch or coffee with no development in it.
Coaching is the most personalized form of leadership development. A skilled coach works on the leader's specific goals within their actual role, provides objective feedback and creates accountability for change. Research by Theeboom and colleagues found coaching to be positively associated with performance and to coping with work demands. The primary limitation is scale: coaching develops one leader at a time, and its effectiveness depends heavily on the quality, expertise, and credibility of the coach.
The pattern
Look across the list and a pattern appears. The methods that change behavior share three ingredients: real work, other people's feedback, and time to practice. The impact is greatest when all three are present together. The methods that disappoint share a different trait: they end when the event ends.
The widely cited 70-20-10 model captures the pattern in rough numbers: about 70 percent of development from challenging assignments, 20 percent from coaching and relationships, 10 percent from formal training (Lombardo and Eichinger, Center for Creative Leadership).
Treat those numbers as a guideline, not a rule. The direction they point is what matters. When a development plan spends most of its energy on the 10 percent (formal training) and neglects the 70, readiness does not improve.
We already know stretch assignments, mentoring and coaching work, so why doesn’t it happen in most companies?
Where leadership development stalls
Two familiar failures deserve attention because they have nothing to do with choosing training methods.
The first is silence. Some organizations never tell candidates they are being developed, fearing entitlement or promises they cannot keep. The candidates read development assignments as extra workload, and motivation drops. The stronger approach is plain: tell people the organization is investing in them for broader responsibility, without promising a specific role. Transparency without a guarantee.
The second is overload. High performers carry the heaviest operational load. When development is layered on top of a full workload, the message is that growth happens on personal time. Development stalls, burnout grows, and the leaders the organization most wants to keep start looking elsewhere. Protected time for learning, reflection, and growth is not a perk. It is part of the plan.
The barrier nobody owns
Even the best development plans can stall during implementation. Direct managers often need employees focused on current deliverables. Human Resources can identify the opportunity but rarely has the authority to enforce it. The employee cannot carry both loads without structural support. So, the most valuable experiences never happen.
This tension is resolved only at the executive level. When development assignments are framed as enterprise investments, priorities change. The chief executive and the chief human resources officer must signal that preparing future leaders is a shared responsibility. It’s an expectation. Without that alignment, development stays theoretical.
The cost of getting it wrong
Organizations often treat leadership development as a soft problem. It is not. Research from Gallup and the Center for Creative Leadership puts the cost of failed leadership transitions and executive turnover at 1.5 to 2 times the leader's annual salary, once search costs, lost
productivity, and disruption are counted. For senior roles, the real figure can reach hundreds of thousands of dollars, or more. Treat development as risk management. The cost of getting it wrong is measured in failed transitions, not in course hours.
Where MentorRINGS fits
MentorRINGS™ was built around real work, feedback, and practice, and because its cohorts sit outside the company, the mentoring, coaching, and perspective do not need a manager's release or another department's favor.
Cohorts combine mentoring from experienced business leaders, coaching on real goals, and cross-functional perspective from peers across organizations and different roles. They are encouraged to seek stretch assignments in their own workplaces, where the stakes are real. That combination is why cohorts accelerate development: they put the 70 and the 20 first, and use formal learning to support them rather than replace them.
Test your own development mix
Three questions will tell you where your own development stands.
1. What share of your development time goes to reading and events, and what share goes to real assignments?
2. Who has seen you under real pressure and told you the truth about it?
3. What real assignment is testing you right now?
If the answers are weak, the development plan needs more than another course. It needs real work, other people's eyes, and time to practice.
From insight to action
Leaders do not become ready by collecting certificates. They become ready by doing harder work, with people who will tell them the truth about it, and with time to learn from both. That is the development worth investing in, and it is what MentorRINGS cohorts are built to provide.
Cohorts starting in January 2027 will bring top talent and high-performing leaders for mentoring, coaching, and cross-functional learning that tests readiness.
For more information, contact Kathy Kilroy, Midwest President, CMP | kkilroy@careermp.com | 847.602.0405
Schedule a Conversation: kkilroy@careermp.com | 847-602-0405
Get in touch
Related posts
Client Testimonials
Predict Fit | Develop Performance | Transform Careers
We help leaders improve our world through deep insights and impactful talent solutions.